stealing therefrom sundry articles of plate, which we had melted down in our own crucibles, and which were no longer, therefore, to be recognised as his, but by evidence against us. All translators show a bold front; for if they come short of the meed of originality, they shift off from them the modesty of responsibility, and unblushingly ascribe all faults to their author. We were therefore easy enough, and ready to make as free with our Rhadamanthus as with our Catullus. Not to be too long — thus commenced our talk. AQUILIUS. The first piece Catullus offers is his dedication-it is to an author to whom I owe a grudge, and perhaps we all of us do. He has caused us some tears, and more visible marks, and I confess something like an aversion to his concise style. It is to Cornelius Nepos. How much more like a modern dedication, than one of Dryden's day, both as to length and matter. AD CORNELIUM NEPOTEM. This little-book-and somewhat light- E'en then, when boldly you stepped forth, In three short books of nervous prose, CURATE.-Queen of wits and sages, -"O Patrima Virgo"-is that translating? GRATIAN.-That's right-have at him! AQUILIUS.-To be sure it is. What English reader would know else that Minerva was meant by "Motherless Virgin?" he would have to go back to the story of Jupiter beating her out of his own brains. So as he is not familiar with the creed, as one of it, I let him into the secret of it at once; and thus out comes the book from the "Minerva Press," 3 σε λαβὲ τὸ βυβλίον.” GRATIAN. (Reads, "O Patrima Virgo," &c.) Well, well-let it pass. The dedication won't pay a long reckoning. We must not look too nicely into the mouth of the book-let it speak for itself. Now, Mr. Curate, what have you? CURATE.-I didn't trouble myself with such a dedication, but passed on to "Ad Passerem Lesbiæ." GRATIAN.-More attractive metal. CURATE. Not at all attractive; for there is considerable difficulty, and as I suppose a corrupted text, before we reach six lines. Here I let the bird loose. Sparrow, minion of my dear, Whom she teases and displeases, Thus inviting savage biting Image burning of my yearning, When at fondness she would play ; Thus she takes her aught that makes her "Tis a balm for her soft sorrow, I would prize it, as the maiden AQUILIUS.-Here lies the difficulty: Another edition has it: make sense of it, and we must not be too nice. AQUILIUS.-Well, then, it possibly means, that she passes off the pain of the bite with a little coquetry and action, as we move about a limb pretty briskly when it tingles. GRATIAN.-O, the cunning-argumentum ad hominem. AQUILIUS. Thus I venture AD PASSEREM LESBLE. Little sparrow, gentle sparrow, Her sweet playmate, whom she petteth, To her bosom come and go. Loving there to hold thee ever, Till you bite her harder still. Then new beauty glistening o'er her, More to soothe or hide her pain. Would thou wert my pretty birdie, For she seeks relief from thee. Birdie, thou shouldst be such treasure Which in flying, Cost the loosening of her zone. CURATE. That may be a possible translation of the difficulty, if the text be somewhat amended; but who ever heard of a hurt from the peck of a sparrow? GRATIAN.-I'll take you into our aviary to-morrow, and you shall try on your own rough-work finger the peck of a bullfinch; and I think you may grant that Lesbia's finger was a little softer. Who would trust the tenderness of a Curate's forefinger, case-hardened as it is with his weekly steel-pen work, and deadened by the nature of it, against all Lesbias and their sparrows. Lesbia's forefinger was the very pattern of a forefinger, soft to touch as to feel that did no work. I dare to say Shakspeare was thinking of such a one, when he said, "The hand of little employment hath the daintier sense." There's something playfully pretty, and lightly tender in this little piece; but I don't see by what link of thought poor Atalanta is brought in, and thus stripped to the skin, as she was outstripped in the race. Admitting the text emendable, may not there be supposed such a connexion as this, that he wishes the bird would be his plaything, that he might lay it as an offering at her feet, that she might take it, as did Atalanta the golden apple, and become herself the winner's reward? Why should not I come in with an ad libitum movement? We, limping rheumaticists, have ever a spiteful desire to trip up the swiftfooted. Now, then, for an old man's limp against Atalanta's speed. Birdie, be my plaything, go- Galatea won her lover by the apple. "Malo me Galatea petit." CURATE.A well thrown apple that golden pippin, grown doubtless from a pip dropt on Mount Ida, and hence the name. We shall not run against you, I perceive. GRATIAN.-Don't talk of golden pippins, or I shall mount my hobby, and go through the genealogy of my whole orchard, and good-bye to Catullus. CURATE.-If you give way to your imagination, you may invent a thousand meanings to the passage; but taking it as I find it, I would attach only this meaning to it,-that Catullus would say, "Lesbia's favourite sparrow "would be as attractive to me as was the golden apple which was thrown in her way when she was racing, to Atalanta. She was to be married to the first youth who could outrun her, so that literally she was very much run after. GRATIAN.-Run after, indeed! Her pursuer, Hippomanes, hadn't my rheumatism (tapping his knee and leg with his stick) or she would have had the apple, and not him. You young men of modern days do not throw your golden apples, but look to pick up what you can. These old tales, or old fables, cast a shade of shame upon our unromantic days. There was a king's daughter offered like a "handy-cap," as if the worthy of mankind were a racing stud. AQUILIUS.-But the lady was not so easily won after all; for there were three golden apples to be picked up: and a bold man was he that threw them, for if he lost, there was neither love nor mercy for him. The condition was worse than Sinbad's. a strange story this of Atalanta and her lover, turned into lions by Cybole. The passage in Catullus being corrupt, there is probably an omission, for, as it is, the transition is very abrupt. It is GRATIAN.-I see the golden apples running about in all directions, and am half asleep, and should be quite so but for this rheumatic hint that it is time to retire: so good-night. Now you will conclude, Eusebius, that I and the Curate made a night and morning of it. On the present occasion, at least, it was not the case; we very soon parted. The following morning, which for the season was freshly sunny, found us on a seat under a verandah near the breakfast room, and close to the aviary, from which we had a moment before come; and the Curate was then wringing his finger after the bites and pecks the bullfinch had given him, which Gratian told him, jocularly, was having a comment on the text at his finger's end; and immediately asked for Catullus. The book was of and the Curate put his finger upon the which he read as he had thus rendered "Death of Lesbia's Sparrow," it: DE PASSERE MORTUO LESBIÆ. Ye Graces, and ye Cupids, mourn, Lies my darling's darling sparrow ! She did love him, and he knew her Whence they tell us none return. AQUILIUS.-It would be childish to blame the poor bird for the crime of dying, as if he had died out of spite; when, if the truth could be told, perhaps the cat killed him. (At this moment, Gratian's favourite cat rubbed herself against his legs, first her face and head, and then her back, and looked up to him, as if begging him to plead for her race; and he did so, and spoke kindly to her, and said, pussey would not kill any bird though he should trust her in the aviary; AQUILIUS. and she, as if she knew what he said, walked off to it, and rubbed her face against the wires, and returned to us again.) Well, I continued, I don't see why the bird should be called wretch for that; and factum male means to express misfortune, not fault. So let the malefactum be the Curate's, and treat him accordingly. GRATIAN.-Come, let us see your bird. Perhaps it may be necessary to kill two with one stone. But I forget-the bird is dead already. DE PASSERE MORTUO LESBIÆ. Ye Cupids, every Queen of Love, That little bird, that honey bird, As fair child knows her mother, knew But archly pert and debonnair, Still further in he fondly nestled, For her alone piped, chirped, and whistled. Whose dreary path none ever dare Retrace, with whom death once hath wrestled. O Orcus' unrequiting shade, Devouring all the good, the dear, Couldst thou not spare one birdling here? CURATE. Is that translating? Lugete, o Veneres, Cupidinesque. You have acted the undertaker to the sorrow, dressed it out, and protracted it, and set it afloat upon a river of wo, with Queens of Love as chiefmourners, hanging out their weepers. AQUILIUS.-Yes, for the Zephyrs to blow. They are light, airy, graceful. They did not come from the first room of the mourning institution, where the soft-slippered man in black gently, and bowing low as he shows his grief-items, whispers, "Much in vogue for deep affliction." The Queens of Love pass on to "the mitigated wo department," and I hope you will confess they have put on their sorrow with grace and taste. But GRATIAN. That's good"the mitigated wo department. But there's a department in these establishments farther on still. There is a little glass door, generally left half open, where there is a most delicate show of "orange blossoms." my good worthy Curate, I don't blame our friend for this little enlargement, because, if it is not in the words of the original, it is every bit of it in the tune and melody of the verses. See how it swells out in full flow in "venustiorum," stays but a moment, and is off again without stop to "puellæ," and that again is repeated ere grief can be said to take any rest. I shall acquit the translator as I would the landscape painter, who, seeing how flowing a line of easy and graceful beauty pervades all nature, and is indeed her great characteristic, rather aims to realise that, than laboriously to dot in every leaf and flower. Characteristic expression is every thing. I am not quite satisfied that either of you have hit the Flendo turgiduli rubent ocelli. CURATE. If we have not, you remember that Juvenal has, and hit whose they are. those eyes rather hard, considering He, however, only meant the hit for Catullus : nec tibi, cujus Turbavit nitídos extinctus passer ocellos. GRATIAN.-Turbavit is "mitigated wo" again: Unlike the Lesbias of our modern years, AQUILIUS.Satire is like a flail, an ugly weapon in a crowd, and hits more than it aims at. I won't allow the blow to be a true hit on Catullus. But let us pass on; there is a vessel waiting for us, though we should be loth to trust to her sheathing, no longer sea-worthy. Our poet now addresses his yacht. Are there many of the "Club " who would write better verses on theirs? DE PHASELO, QUO IN PATRIAM REVECTUS ET. This bark that now, my friends, you see, Than other craft, whate'er the tree She asked the Cyclad Isles to say Can they deny-rough Adria's shore, |